New York City’s new Community Opportunity to Purchase Act is the wrong tool for a real problem. It won’t stop anyone from breaking ground tomorrow. But it makes every building it touches harder to sell, finance and fix, and the tenants it is meant to protect will pay for that.
I didn’t learn real estate in a classroom. My Dad, his partner and I built single-family homes in San Diego. I learned early that the day you break ground is not the day you make your money. You make it when the building leases up, refinances or sells. Every lender, partner and buyer you will ever meet underwrites that exit before they write a check.
On November 10, Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed COPA into law. It goes straight at the exit. Here is how I read it as a builder, why I think it is likely to come west, and what I would ask of the people writing the next version.
What COPA does
COPA gives certified nonprofits the first chance to buy certain apartment buildings before an owner can sell them on the open market. It takes effect in November 2027, after the city’s housing agency (HPD) writes the rules and certifies which nonprofits qualify.
• Which buildings: rentals with four or more units that have serious unresolved code violations, documented tenant harassment findings, or an affordability agreement with HPD. Lawmakers narrowed the list from about 10,000 buildings to about 2,100.
• What’s exempt: owner-occupied buildings with five or fewer units, buildings whose only affordability restriction comes from the 421-a tax program, and court-supervised foreclosure sales.
• How it works: the owner notifies HPD and the qualified nonprofits. They get 20 days to say they’re interested and 70 more to make an offer. If the owner turns that offer down, the nonprofit can match a third-party deal for up to a year.
• What it doesn’t do: it doesn’t force a sale, set a price or come with a dedicated pot of money for nonprofits to buy with.
This isn’t a new idea. Washington, D.C. has given tenants a version of this right since 1980. San Francisco passed its own COPA in 2019. New York’s is now the largest program in the country.
What it gets right
The problem COPA goes after is real. Some buildings with years of open violations change hands to buyers who plan to squeeze the rent roll, not fix the roof. Tenants in those buildings have no say in who their next landlord will be.
I’ll give this version of the law credit for three things:
1. It got narrower. The first draft would have covered about 10,000 buildings. This one covers about 2,100, aimed at buildings already in trouble or already carrying public affordability commitments.
2. It doesn’t set the price. The owner can still market the building, negotiate with other buyers and say no to a low offer.
3. It protects buildings the public already paid for. When taxpayers have subsidized affordability, it’s fair to ask that a mission-driven buyer get a look before that affordability is sold off.
But credit for intentions is not credit for results. Ask anyone who builds or finances housing what this does to the next deal.
Where it falls short
Housing gets built because capital believes it can get out. COPA puts City Hall and a preferred class of buyer between an owner and that exit. Here is the damage I expect.
1. A slower exit is a lower value. A covered owner now waits up to 90 days before selling freely. Then a nonprofit can match any deal for a year. Buyers know that. Some won’t spend $50,000 on due diligence for a deal they can lose at the finish line. Fewer bidders means lower prices, and lower prices mean less equity for the next project.
2. It hits the buildings that most need new money. A building with open violations usually needs a buyer with capital and a plan. Those are the value-add investors and rehab developers who now have to wait behind a nonprofit that may or may not have the money. New York’s own Council acknowledged that nonprofits can wait a long time for city funding.
3. It catches affordable housing on the way out. If you take HPD money and sign a regulatory agreement, your eventual sale is now covered. That’s a cost a developer will price in on day one. The likely result is fewer developers taking public subsidy, or asking for more of it.
4. It complicates 1031 exchanges. An exchange has to close within 180 days. A 90-day notice period plus a one-year right to match makes that a gamble for any owner whose next purchase depends on this sale.
5. The rules aren’t written yet. HPD will define much of what is covered and how notices work over the next year. Lawyers expect court challenges. Lenders hate uncertainty more than they hate bad news.
6. Who buys isn’t the problem. Owners point to rising costs, a two-year rent freeze on stabilized units and refinancing trouble as the real causes of distress. A new buyer inherits those same numbers. If the rent roll can’t carry the building, a nonprofit owner will face the same math, often with less capital behind it.
7. We’ve seen this movie. D.C. has had a tenant version since 1980. It produced few sales and a lot of slow deals. San Francisco’s COPA has been on the books since 2019, and a Shelterforce report counted about 300 affordable units bought through it. For a city the size of New York, that is a long wait for a short list of results.
8. It hands out a right with no money behind it. COPA doesn’t create a dedicated acquisition fund. At the signing, Mayor Mamdani announced no new money for COPA purchases. The city’s budget sets aside more than $2 billion over two years for affordable housing preservation, but none of it is earmarked for COPA.
So how is this supposed to work? A nonprofit gets 70 days to make an offer. In that time it has to line up a lender, an appraisal, inspections and city subsidy from programs the Council itself admits move slowly. Even Cypress Hills LDC, whose building hosted the signing, said community groups still need acquisition financing, preservation funding and technical help.
San Francisco at least paired its COPA with a funding source, its Small Sites Program. New York’s version gives nonprofits a seat at the table and nothing to bid with. I expect offers that can’t close, owners who lose 90 days, and buildings that sit while the repairs wait.
Will it come west?
It already has. The question is how far and how fast.
• San Francisco passed its COPA in 2019. It gives certified nonprofits the first chance to buy buildings with three or more units.
• Berkeley and Los Angeles County have had community campaigns for similar laws, and advocates have pushed for a statewide Right of First Purchase in Sacramento.
• San Jose is the counterexample. The California Apartment Association organized and kept a COPA from passing there.
• San Diego already has an ordinance aimed at preserving deed-restricted affordable housing, a narrower rule but the same family of ideas.
• Beyond California, Montgomery and Prince George’s Counties in Maryland and a pilot in Chicago have their own versions.
New York matters because of its size. Whatever happens there over the next few years, good or bad, will be the example every city council points to. My guess is that California sees it city by city, starting in the Bay Area and Los Angeles, before Sacramento takes it statewide. The first targets will look like New York’s: buildings with code violations and buildings carrying public affordability agreements.
What I’d ask of policymakers
My first advice to any city considering one of these: don’t. Fund nonprofit buyers directly and let them compete for buildings in the open market like everyone else. If you pass one anyway, build it so capital stays in the room. Five changes would make a big difference:
1. Fund the buyer before you give it rights. A first look means little if the nonprofit can’t close. Pair the law with an acquisition fund and fast underwriting, so a qualified offer is a real offer.
2. Shorten the clock. Ninety days to make an offer and a year to match is too long for any market. Thirty days to offer and a short, defined window to match would keep deals moving and keep 1031 exchanges possible.
3. Protect new construction and existing agreements. Exempt new buildings, and don’t apply the law to regulatory agreements signed before it passed. Developers need to know the rules of the exit on the day they take public money.
4. Write the rules before the law takes effect. Owners, lenders and buyers need to know exactly which buildings are covered and how notice works before the first sale.
5. Fix the operating math too. A building that can’t cover its costs will struggle under any owner. Rent policy, property taxes and repair funding matter as much as who holds the deed.
What I’d tell developers and owners now
You don’t have to own a building in New York for this to matter. If you build or own rental housing anywhere one of these laws is under discussion, here is what I would do:
• Underwrite a longer exit. Add 90 to 120 days to the sale timeline for any project with recorded affordability restrictions, and stress-test the price for a smaller pool of bidders.
• Don’t count on a tight 1031. If your next purchase depends on selling into one of these laws, line up a backup plan.
• Read the regulatory agreement twice. Before you take public money, know what it means for your exit, not just your rents.
• Keep the violations cleared. In New York, open code violations are one of the triggers. A well-maintained building stays out of the conversation.
• Show up early. These laws get written in council hearings and committee rooms. Builders who explain how deals actually work, with real numbers, get better laws than builders who only show up to oppose them.
The bottom line
COPA answers a real problem with the wrong tool. Distressed buildings don’t need a new gatekeeper at the closing table. They need capital, repairs and rents that cover the bills. Housing gets built when people can see a way in and a way out. Make the way out slower and less certain, and that capital will build in another city.
Building with my Dad taught me that you don’t make money on a deal until you can get out of it. That is just as true for a nonprofit as it is for a developer. If we want more housing, let’s write laws that keep the door open for everyone who can build it and take care of it.
Sources
• Brownstoner: Troubled rental buildings could become affordable housing with new law
• amNY: Council passes narrowed COPA
• The Real Deal: Modified COPA nears passage despite real estate pushback
• The Real Deal: NYC multifamily owners and brokers fear COPA
• City Journal: New York’s special deal for nonprofit landlords
• Local Housing Solutions: Rights of first refusal
• Enterprise Community Partners: California opportunity to purchase campaigns
• Shelterforce: San Francisco COPA results
• National Housing Trust: Preserving housing through community ownership
• Pulse: Adding context to COPA, on D.C.’s TOPA track record
• City of San Francisco: Community Opportunity to Purchase Act and the Small Sites Program
